On Halloween night in New Salem, Radio DJs Chilly Billy (Corey Taylor) and Paul (Zach Galligan) tell a twisted anthology of terrifying local myths that lead to a grim end for small-town residents.

When Jack, a groomsman, leaves for his best friend's wedding several states away, he's asked to pick up Samantha, a stranded bridesmaid. Jack discovers they've met before and have had a less than friendly past.