The Penitent Thief is the story of the two unnamed men who were crucified alongside Jesus and how they came to be beside him on the cross that fateful day. The Penitent Thief is an epic story that begins with the journey of the Magi

When mean-spirited Jake gets hit by a car, the only person around to take care of him is his childhood friend Sam. He agrees to help Jake recover but when Sam's high school crush Zoe moves back to town, it's every man for himself.

It follows 15-year old Quinn Perkins, who will be spending the summer working as an intern with her best friend Daniela. Mysterious events start to occur, and they assume that they are being haunted by local legend Everly Fallow.